Disclaimer: Tools First supports our readers with thousands of hours of research to help you find the right products for your needs and make your life easier. You support us through our carefully chosen links that may earn us a commission.
Whether you’re just dabbling in DIY projects at home or need a serious dust collection system for your professional workshop, the tools you use to help get your work area clean are crucial.
Inhaling lots of dust and wood particles can pose a serious threat to your health, so you need to clean your workspace as thoroughly as possible.
That being said, should you invest in a dust collector or a shop vac? In this brief guide, we’ll explore why both are important for anyone who does a lot of DIY projects or professional woodworking.
What is a Shop Vac?
Contrary to popular belief, a dust collector and a shop vacuum are not the same thing, so it’s important to understand differences between them. The major differences lie in the size of the material they can handle and the magnitude of the space in which you’ll use them.
If you do not currently have a vacuum designed to clean up your workshop, investing in a shop vac is a wise decision. Not only can a shop vacuum help you clean up faster than a standard vacuum can, but shop vacs are also designed to handle a more comprehensive range of material than your traditional vacuum.
What is a shop vac used for?
Generally speaking, shop vacuums are excellent for helping clean up small to medium amounts of wood chips or sawdust after a long day’s work. They can also be used to suck up small amounts of water or even glass.
Most shop vacuums function with a wide-take-all-approach. You can quickly clean up the majority of the mess in your workshop with a shop vacuum. However, it won’t always be able to suck up every small particle of wood or dust in the area. Shop vacuums typically have one filter system to collect all the debris and other dust you put in them.
Think of a shop vacuum like the very first car you bought. You probably won’t get the most expensive car right when you turn the legal age to drive, but you still need a vehicle to help you get around town. Having any car is better than no car, but at the same time, there are always better options with more features.
If you’re only dabbling in home improvement projects, a shop vacuum is a great tool to help you keep your workstation clean. It’s useful for cleaning up many different messes, but it isn’t a specialized tool.
What is a Dust Collector?
Dust collectors are crucial for anyone who is seriously invested in woodworking, as it is one of the most effective ways to clean your workspace and ensure no dust remains.
Designed to be extremely useful in cleaning up small particles of debris, dust collectors operate in a slightly more sophisticated way. Dust collectors are built to quickly clean up a wide area of dust and particulars, unlike the shop vacuum, which remains limited in its ability to vacuum large areas at once.
Unlike shop vacs, most dust collectors contain two compartments in which the debris and dust are separated and filtered. The shop vacuum can be effectively used to clean up small areas, whereas dust collectors will work to cover more ground effectively.
Another option, a dust extractor, operates similarly to a standard dust collector, but it’s specifically designed to clean the air of dust and other pollutants that can be harmful to your lungs. Working in a space where the air is full of particulates can cause serious damage in the long term, and it’s crucial you have a proper dust collection system in place to ensure you don’t put your health at risk.
The Importance of dust collectors
When you breathe in small particulate matter, your lungs can uptake it into your bloodstream along with oxygen. Over time, this can cause a number of lung problems, from a persistent cough up to and including lung cancer. Wood dust was officially classified as a known carcinogen in 2002. Removing dust from your shop is about more than just cleanliness – it’s about your health, too.
If you have a number of heavy duty, stationary tools that leave a lot of dust or wood particles, a dust collector is a necessary piece of equipment to maintain a healthy working environment.
Shop Vac vs. Dust Collector: How to Choose
When choosing between a dust collector and a shop vacuum, the metric cubic-feet-per-minute (CFM) can help you decide which cleaning tool is right for you.
The higher the cubic-feet-per-minute of your tool, the more effective it is at cleaning.
Different types of debris require a different standard of CFM to be effectively vacuumed, so it’s important that whichever option you choose has a high enough CFM for the material you’ll be using it on.
Another measurement you can use to determine which vacuum is right for you is the overall lift count of your vacuum. The higher the lift count, the more powerful the vacuum is and the more capable to pick up heavier debris.
Ultimately, if you’re a serious craftsperson, you should consider investing in a shop vacuum, dust extractor, and dust collector to give you all the tools you need to effectively clean your workspace. While having one of the vacuums is better than having none, having all three at your disposal is the best way to ensure a clean shop with clean air.